Add User Context To The Dynamic Menu

by ADMIN 37 views

=====================================================

Problem Description

Are you tired of seeing irrelevant menu items that don't cater to your unique user context? The current Dynamic Menu system lacks the ability to provide a curated experience for each user, resulting in a cluttered and confusing interface. This is a common problem faced by many users, and it's time to address it.

Solution Overview

The proposed solution aims to enhance the Dynamic Menu system by incorporating user context. This will enable users to see only the menu items that are relevant to their specific situation. The solution involves several key components:

  • User-based menu item visibility: Menu items will be visible only to users who have access to the corresponding feature. For example, if a user has users.feature_a=true, they will see a menu item related to feature A, while users with users.feature_a=false will not see it.
  • Section context expansion: Sections will not be populated if all rows under that section evaluate to include=false. This will prevent empty sections from displaying in the menu.
  • SQL query integration: While not a primary focus, it would be beneficial to allow SQL queries to be executed in relation to the Dynamic menu to build/filter menu items per user login.

Solution Implementation

To implement the proposed solution, we will need to make the following changes:

1. User-based menu item visibility

To achieve user-based menu item visibility, we will need to modify the Dynamic Menu system to take into account the user's feature access. This can be done by introducing a new field in the menu item table that stores the user's feature access. We will then use this field to determine whether a menu item should be visible to a particular user.

-- Create a new field in the menu item table to store user feature access
ALTER TABLE menu_items ADD COLUMN user_feature_access VARCHAR(255);

-- Update the menu item visibility logic to take into account user feature access
UPDATE menu_items
SET visible = CASE
    WHEN users.feature_a = TRUE AND user_feature_access = 'feature_a' THEN TRUE
    ELSE FALSE
END;

2. Section context expansion

To expand the section context, we will need to modify the Dynamic Menu system to check if all rows under a section evaluate to include=false. If so, the section will not be populated.

-- Create a new field in the section table to store the include status of all rows
ALTER TABLE section_rows ADD COLUMN include_status VARCHAR(255);

-- Update the section population logic to take into account the include status of all rows
UPDATE sections
SET populated = CASE
    WHEN ALL(include_status = 'false') THEN FALSE
    ELSE TRUE
END;

3. SQL query integration

To integrate SQL queries with the Dynamic menu, we will need to create a new field in the menu item table that stores the SQL query. We will then use this field to execute the query and build/filter menu items per user login.

-- Create a new field in the menu item table to store the SQL query
ALTER TABLE menu_items ADD COLUMN sql_query VARCHAR(255);

-- Update the menu item building logic to take into account the SQL query
UPDATE menu_items
SET menu_item = (
    SELECT *
    FROM (
        SELECT *
        menu_item_table
        WHERE users.feature_a = TRUE
    ) AS subquery
    WHERE sql_query = 'SELECT * FROM menu_item_table WHERE users.feature_a = TRUE'
);

Alternatives Considered

Before proposing the above solution, we considered several alternatives:

  • Adding calculated/stored fields to the reference table: This approach would allow us to access row-level data on the reference table, but it would still evaluate globally instead of per-user.
  • Using a different data structure: We considered using a different data structure, such as a graph database, to store menu items and their relationships. However, this would require significant changes to the existing system and may not be feasible.

Additional Context

A similar question has been raised in the past (#2453). While the proposed solution addresses the specific issue of user-based menu item visibility, it also touches on the broader topic of Dynamic Menu system enhancements.

Conclusion

The proposed solution aims to enhance the Dynamic Menu system by incorporating user context. By introducing user-based menu item visibility, section context expansion, and SQL query integration, we can provide a more curated experience for each user. While there are alternatives to consider, the proposed solution is the most feasible and effective approach to addressing the problem.

Future Work

Future work on this project may include:

  • Implementing the proposed solution: We will need to implement the proposed solution in the Dynamic Menu system.
  • Testing and validation: We will need to test and validate the proposed solution to ensure it meets the requirements and does not introduce any new issues.
  • Refining the solution: Based on feedback and testing results, we may need to refine the proposed solution to improve its effectiveness and usability.

=====================================================

Q: What is the current issue with the Dynamic Menu system?

A: The current Dynamic Menu system lacks the ability to provide a curated experience for each user, resulting in a cluttered and confusing interface. Users see irrelevant menu items that don't cater to their unique user context.

Q: How does the proposed solution address this issue?

A: The proposed solution introduces user-based menu item visibility, section context expansion, and SQL query integration. This enables users to see only the menu items that are relevant to their specific situation.

Q: What is user-based menu item visibility?

A: User-based menu item visibility is a feature that allows menu items to be visible only to users who have access to the corresponding feature. For example, if a user has users.feature_a=true, they will see a menu item related to feature A, while users with users.feature_a=false will not see it.

Q: How does section context expansion work?

A: Section context expansion is a feature that prevents empty sections from displaying in the menu. If all rows under a section evaluate to include=false, the section will not be populated.

Q: Can SQL queries be executed in relation to the Dynamic menu?

A: Yes, SQL queries can be executed in relation to the Dynamic menu to build/filter menu items per user login. This feature is still in development, but it will provide a powerful way to customize the menu experience for each user.

Q: What are the benefits of the proposed solution?

A: The proposed solution provides several benefits, including:

  • A more curated experience for each user
  • Improved usability and accessibility
  • Enhanced customization options for menu items and sections
  • Better support for complex menu structures and relationships

Q: What are the challenges of implementing the proposed solution?

A: The challenges of implementing the proposed solution include:

  • Integrating user-based menu item visibility and section context expansion with the existing Dynamic Menu system
  • Developing a robust and scalable SQL query execution system
  • Ensuring seamless integration with other features and components of the application

Q: What is the timeline for implementing the proposed solution?

A: The timeline for implementing the proposed solution is still being determined. However, we anticipate that it will take several months to complete, depending on the complexity of the implementation and the availability of resources.

Q: How can users provide feedback and suggestions for the proposed solution?

A: Users can provide feedback and suggestions for the proposed solution by submitting a ticket or contacting the development team directly. We value user input and will do our best to incorporate feedback and suggestions into the implementation.

Q: What are the next steps for the proposed solution?

A: The next steps for the proposed solution include:

  • Finalizing the implementation plan and timeline
  • Developing a detailed design document and technical specification
  • Beginning development and testing of the proposed solution

Q: How can users stay up-to-date with the progress of the proposed solution?

A: Users can stay up-to-date with the progress of the proposed solution by:

  • Following the development team's blog and social media channels
  • Subscribing to the application's newsletter and release notes
  • Participating in user testing and feedback sessions

Q: What the potential risks and challenges associated with the proposed solution?

A: The potential risks and challenges associated with the proposed solution include:

  • Integration issues with the existing Dynamic Menu system
  • Complexity and scalability challenges with the SQL query execution system
  • User adoption and training challenges

Q: How will the proposed solution be tested and validated?

A: The proposed solution will be tested and validated through a combination of:

  • Unit testing and integration testing
  • User testing and feedback sessions
  • Performance and scalability testing
  • Security and compliance testing

Q: What are the expected outcomes and benefits of the proposed solution?

A: The expected outcomes and benefits of the proposed solution include:

  • Improved user experience and satisfaction
  • Increased adoption and engagement
  • Enhanced customization and flexibility
  • Better support for complex menu structures and relationships