Autoload Should Ignore Saved Positions Of Autoloaded Files

by ADMIN 59 views

Understanding the Issue

When using the autoload feature in mpv, it can be frustrating when the saved positions of autoloaded files are taken into account. This can lead to unexpected behavior, especially when trying to start from the beginning of videos. In this article, we will explore the issue and propose a solution to add an option for autoload to ignore saved positions of autoloaded files.

The Problem

Let's take a closer look at the scenario that led to this issue:

  1. Save position on quit: You have save-position-on-quit=yes set in your mpv.conf file. This means that mpv will save the current position of the video when you quit the player.
  2. Autoload directory: You have already watched all files in a directory, and you want to play them again using the autoload feature.
  3. File 1 is loaded: You play File 1 from the directory, and it is loaded into the player.
  4. File 2 is loaded: Since File 1 is already at the end, File 2 is loaded into the player.
  5. Continue cycle: The autoload feature continues to load the next files in the directory.

The Issue

When you toggle autoload on from the controls above the timeline, you typically want to start from the beginning of videos instead of resuming. However, with the current behavior, mpv will resume from the saved position of the previous file. This can be confusing and frustrating, especially if you want to start from the beginning of each video.

The Solution

To address this issue, we propose adding an option to autoload to ignore saved positions of autoloaded files. This would allow users to start from the beginning of videos when using the autoload feature, while still saving the positions of files when autoload is off.

Benefits

Adding this option would provide several benefits:

  • Improved user experience: Users would no longer be confused by the unexpected behavior of autoload resuming from the saved position of the previous file.
  • Increased flexibility: Users would have more control over how autoload behaves, allowing them to choose whether to start from the beginning or resume from the saved position.
  • Better alignment with user expectations: The default behavior of autoload would be more in line with user expectations, making it easier for users to use the feature effectively.

Implementation

To implement this feature, we would need to add a new option to the autoload feature. This option would allow users to choose whether to ignore saved positions of autoloaded files. Here is an example of how this could be implemented:

  • Option name: autoload-ignore-saved-positions
  • Default value: no
  • Description: Ignore saved positions of autoloaded files when using the autoload feature.

Conclusion

In conclusion, adding an option for autoload to ignore saved positions of autoloaded files would improve the user experience, increase flexibility, and better align with user expectations. We believe that this feature would be a valuable addition to the mpv player, and we hope that it will be considered for implementation in the future.

Future Development

As mpv continues to evolve, we hope to see further of the autoload feature. Some potential future developments could include:

  • Improved handling of file metadata: mpv could improve its handling of file metadata, such as file names, directories, and timestamps.
  • Enhanced user interface: mpv could enhance its user interface to make it easier for users to manage their autoload settings and preferences.
  • Support for additional file formats: mpv could add support for additional file formats, making it a more versatile and powerful media player.

References

Acknowledgments

Frequently Asked Questions

In our previous article, we discussed the issue of autoload ignoring saved positions of autoloaded files and proposed a solution to add an option for autoload to ignore saved positions of autoloaded files. In this article, we will answer some frequently asked questions about this feature.

Q: What is the current behavior of autoload when it comes to saved positions?

A: Currently, when you use the autoload feature, mpv will resume from the saved position of the previous file. This means that if you have save-position-on-quit=yes set in your mpv.conf file, mpv will save the current position of the video when you quit the player, and then resume from that position when you use the autoload feature.

Q: Why is this behavior a problem?

A: This behavior can be confusing and frustrating, especially if you want to start from the beginning of each video when using the autoload feature. It can also lead to unexpected behavior, such as loading the next file in the directory before the previous file has finished playing.

Q: How would the new option work?

A: The new option, autoload-ignore-saved-positions, would allow users to choose whether to ignore saved positions of autoloaded files. When this option is enabled, mpv would start from the beginning of each video when using the autoload feature, rather than resuming from the saved position of the previous file.

Q: What are the benefits of this new option?

A: The benefits of this new option include:

  • Improved user experience: Users would no longer be confused by the unexpected behavior of autoload resuming from the saved position of the previous file.
  • Increased flexibility: Users would have more control over how autoload behaves, allowing them to choose whether to start from the beginning or resume from the saved position.
  • Better alignment with user expectations: The default behavior of autoload would be more in line with user expectations, making it easier for users to use the feature effectively.

Q: How would this option be implemented?

A: To implement this option, we would need to add a new option to the autoload feature. This option would allow users to choose whether to ignore saved positions of autoloaded files. Here is an example of how this could be implemented:

  • Option name: autoload-ignore-saved-positions
  • Default value: no
  • Description: Ignore saved positions of autoloaded files when using the autoload feature.

Q: What are the potential drawbacks of this new option?

A: Some potential drawbacks of this new option include:

  • Increased complexity: Adding a new option to the autoload feature could increase the complexity of the feature and make it more difficult to use.
  • Potential for confusion: Users may be confused by the new option and its behavior, especially if they are not familiar with the autoload feature.

Q: How can users get involved in the development of this feature?

A: Users can get involved in the development of this feature by:

  • Reporting bugs and issues: Users can report bugs and related to the autoload feature and suggest improvements.
  • Providing feedback: Users can provide feedback on the new option and its behavior.
  • Contributing to the development process: Users can contribute to the development process by submitting patches or code changes.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the new option autoload-ignore-saved-positions would provide users with more control over how autoload behaves and improve the user experience. We hope that this article has been helpful in answering some frequently asked questions about this feature and providing more information about its benefits and implementation.

References

Acknowledgments

We would like to thank the mpv development team for their hard work and dedication to creating a powerful and flexible media player. We hope that this article has been helpful in highlighting the importance of adding an option for autoload to ignore saved positions of autoloaded files.