Default Shadcn UI Has Different Color Especially For Dark Mode
The Problem
When installing components from Shadcn using pnpm dlx shadcn@latest add <component>, you may notice a difference in color, particularly in dark mode. This issue arises when comparing the installed component with the one used in Tweakcn. The component from Shadcn exhibits more dark mode-specific styling, utilizing the dark: prefix. This discrepancy can be puzzling, and you may be wondering if there's a solution to this problem.
Understanding the Issue
To better comprehend the issue, let's examine the code for the Button component installed from Shadcn and the one used in Tweakcn.
Button Variant Installed from Shadcn
The Button component installed from Shadcn uses a more extensive set of dark mode-specific styles, as evident from the code snippet below:
// Button component from Shadcn
import { Button } from '@shadcn/ui';
export default function ButtonExample() {
return (
<div>
<Button variant="solid" colorScheme="blue" size="lg">
Button
</Button>
<Button variant="outline" colorScheme="blue" size="lg">
Outline Button
</Button>
<Button variant="ghost" colorScheme="blue" size="lg">
Ghost Button
</Button>
<Button variant="link" colorScheme="blue" size="lg">
Link Button
</Button>
</div>
);
}
Button Variant in Tweakcn
On the other hand, the Button component used in Tweakcn has a more minimalist approach to dark mode styling, as shown in the code snippet below:
// Button component from Tweakcn
import { Button } from '@tweakcn/ui';
export default function ButtonExample() {
return (
<div>
<Button variant="solid" colorScheme="blue" size="lg">
Button
</Button>
<Button variant="outline" colorScheme="blue" size="lg">
Outline Button
</Button>
</div>
);
}
Analyzing the Difference
Upon closer inspection, it becomes apparent that the Button component from Shadcn uses a more extensive set of dark mode-specific styles, including the dark: prefix. This is evident in the code snippet below:
// Dark mode styles for Button component from Shadcn
export const buttonStyles = {
baseStyle: {
_focus: {
boxShadow: 'none',
},
},
sizes: {
md: {
px: 4,
py: 2,
},
},
variants: {
solid: {
bg: 'blue.500',
color: 'white',
_hover: {
bg: 'blue.700',
},
_dark: {
bg: 'blue.200',
color: 'white',
},
},
outline: {
border: '1px solid',
borderColor: 'blue.500',
_hover: {
borderColor: 'blue.700',
},
_dark: {
borderColor: 'blue.200',
},
},
ghost: {
bg: 'transparent',
: 'blue.500',
_hover: {
color: 'blue.700',
},
_dark: {
color: 'blue.200',
},
},
link: {
bg: 'transparent',
color: 'blue.500',
_hover: {
color: 'blue.700',
},
_dark: {
color: 'blue.200',
},
},
},
};
Solution
To resolve this issue, you can modify the Button component from Shadcn to match the styling used in Tweakcn. This can be achieved by removing the dark: prefix from the dark mode styles and using a more minimalist approach to styling.
Alternatively, you can create a custom Button component that combines the best features of both Shadcn and Tweakcn. This can be done by creating a new component that uses the dark: prefix for dark mode styles and the more minimalist approach used in Tweakcn.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the difference in color between the Button component installed from Shadcn and the one used in Tweakcn can be attributed to the use of dark mode-specific styles in Shadcn. By modifying the Button component from Shadcn to match the styling used in Tweakcn or creating a custom Button component that combines the best features of both, you can resolve this issue and achieve a consistent look and feel across your application.
Recommendations
- When installing components from Shadcn, ensure that you understand the styling used in the component and how it may differ from the styling used in Tweakcn.
- Consider creating a custom Button component that combines the best features of both Shadcn and Tweakcn.
- Use a consistent approach to styling across your application to ensure a cohesive look and feel.
Future Development
In future developments, it would be beneficial to standardize the styling used in Shadcn and Tweakcn to ensure consistency across components. This can be achieved by creating a shared styling library that can be used across both frameworks.
References
Appendix
Below are the code snippets used in this article:
Button Variant Installed from Shadcn
// Button component from Shadcn
import { Button } from '@shadcn/ui';
export default function ButtonExample() {
return (
<div>
<Button variant="solid" colorScheme="blue" size="lg">
Button
</Button>
<Button variant="outline" colorScheme="blue" size="lg">
Outline Button
</Button>
<Button variant="ghost" colorScheme="blue" size="lg">
Ghost Button
</Button>
<Button variant="link" colorScheme="blue" size="lg">
Link Button
</Button>
</div>
);
}
Button Variant in Tweakcn
// Button component from Tweakcn
import { Button } from '@tweakcn/ui';
export default function ButtonExample() {
return (
<div>
<Button variant="solid" colorScheme="blue" size="lg Button
</Button>
<Button variant="outline" colorScheme="blue" size="lg">
Outline Button
</Button>
</div>
);
}
Dark Mode Styles for Button Component from Shadcn
// Dark mode styles for Button component from Shadcn
export const buttonStyles = {
baseStyle: {
_focus: {
boxShadow: 'none',
},
},
sizes: {
md: {
px: 4,
py: 2,
},
},
variants: {
solid: {
bg: 'blue.500',
color: 'white',
_hover: {
bg: 'blue.700',
},
_dark: {
bg: 'blue.200',
color: 'white',
},
},
outline: {
border: '1px solid',
borderColor: 'blue.500',
_hover: {
borderColor: 'blue.700',
},
_dark: {
borderColor: 'blue.200',
},
},
ghost: {
bg: 'transparent',
color: 'blue.500',
_hover: {
color: 'blue.700',
},
_dark: {
color: 'blue.200',
},
},
link: {
bg: 'transparent',
color: 'blue.500',
_hover: {
color: 'blue.700',
},
_dark: {
color: 'blue.200',
},
},
},
};
```<br/>
**Default Shadcn UI has Different Color Especially for Dark Mode: Q&A**
====================================================================
**Q: What is the main difference between the Button component installed from Shadcn and the one used in Tweakcn?**
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A: The main difference lies in the dark mode-specific styles used in Shadcn. The Button component from Shadcn uses a more extensive set of dark mode styles, including the `dark:` prefix, whereas the Button component used in Tweakcn has a more minimalist approach to dark mode styling.
**Q: Why does the Button component from Shadcn have more dark mode-specific styles?**
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A: The Button component from Shadcn is designed to provide a more comprehensive set of dark mode styles, which can be used to create a consistent look and feel across the application. This includes using the `dark:` prefix to define dark mode styles for each variant of the Button component.
**Q: How can I resolve the issue of different colors between the Button component installed from Shadcn and the one used in Tweakcn?**
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A: To resolve this issue, you can modify the Button component from Shadcn to match the styling used in Tweakcn. Alternatively, you can create a custom Button component that combines the best features of both Shadcn and Tweakcn.
**Q: What are the benefits of creating a custom Button component?**
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A: Creating a custom Button component can provide several benefits, including:
* Consistency across the application: By creating a custom Button component, you can ensure that the styling is consistent across the application.
* Flexibility: A custom Button component can be designed to meet the specific needs of your application.
* Reusability: A custom Button component can be reused across the application, reducing the need for duplicate code.
**Q: How can I create a custom Button component that combines the best features of both Shadcn and Tweakcn?**
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A: To create a custom Button component, you can start by identifying the key features of both Shadcn and Tweakcn that you want to include in your custom component. You can then use a combination of CSS and JavaScript to create a custom Button component that meets your needs.
**Q: What are some best practices for creating a custom Button component?**
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A: Some best practices for creating a custom Button component include:
* Keeping it simple: Avoid over-complicating the design of your custom Button component.
* Using a consistent design language: Ensure that your custom Button component follows a consistent design language across the application.
* Testing thoroughly: Test your custom Button component thoroughly to ensure that it works as expected.
**Q: How can I ensure that my custom Button component is accessible?**
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A: To ensure that your custom Button component is accessible, you can follow these best practices:
* Use semantic HTML: Use semantic HTML to define the structure of your custom Button component.
* Provide alternative text: Provide alternative text for your custom Button component to ensure that it is accessible to screen readers.
* Test for accessibility: Test your custom Button component for accessibility to ensure that it meets the required standards.
**: What are some common mistakes to avoid when creating a custom Button component?**
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A: Some common mistakes to avoid when creating a custom Button component include:
* Over-complicating the design: Avoid over-complicating the design of your custom Button component.
* Failing to test: Failing to test your custom Button component thoroughly can lead to bugs and accessibility issues.
* Not following a consistent design language: Failing to follow a consistent design language can lead to a disjointed user experience.
**Q: How can I troubleshoot issues with my custom Button component?**
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A: To troubleshoot issues with your custom Button component, you can follow these steps:
* Identify the issue: Identify the specific issue you are experiencing with your custom Button component.
* Check the code: Check the code of your custom Button component to ensure that it is correct.
* Test thoroughly: Test your custom Button component thoroughly to ensure that it works as expected.
**Q: What are some resources for learning more about creating custom Button components?**
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A: Some resources for learning more about creating custom Button components include:
* [Shadcn UI Documentation](https://shadcn.com/docs/ui)
* [Tweakcn UI Documentation](https://tweakcn.com/docs/ui)
* [MDN Web Docs](https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/CSS)
**Q: How can I stay up-to-date with the latest developments in Shadcn and Tweakcn?**
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A: To stay up-to-date with the latest developments in Shadcn and Tweakcn, you can follow these steps:
* Check the official documentation: Check the official documentation for Shadcn and Tweakcn for the latest updates.
* Follow the community: Follow the community of developers who use Shadcn and Tweakcn to stay informed about the latest developments.
* Attend conferences and meetups: Attend conferences and meetups to learn more about the latest developments in Shadcn and Tweakcn.