Inconsistent Behavior When Copying With Context Menu Vs Ctrl + C From RTE

by ADMIN 74 views

Introduction

When working with rich text editors (RTE) in Joplin, users often rely on the context menu or the keyboard shortcut Ctrl + C to copy formatted text. However, a recent observation has revealed an inconsistency in the behavior of these two methods. In this article, we will delve into the details of this issue, explore the expected behavior, and discuss potential solutions.

Operating System and Joplin Version

The issue was reported on a Windows operating system with Joplin version 3.3.12. The desktop version information is as follows:

  • Joplin 3.3.12 (prod, win32)
  • Device: win32, Intel(R) Core(TM) Ultra 7 256V
  • Client ID: bce815a5276340048b4ff1dce1c47aee
  • Sync Version: 3
  • Profile Version: 47
  • Keychain Supported: Yes
  • Alternative instance ID: -
  • Revision: 4d790b6
  • Backup: 1.4.3
  • Journal: 2.0.0
  • Note Tabs: 1.4.0

Current Behavior

The current behavior of copying formatted text from the RTE in Joplin is as follows:

  1. Create a note with formatting: Create a new note in Joplin and add some formatting, such as bold text.
  2. Highlight the formatted text: Select the bold text in the RTE.
  3. Copy with Ctrl + C: Press Ctrl + C to copy the selected text.
  4. Paste into a plaintext app: Paste the copied text into an app that only accepts plaintext, such as Notepad.
  5. Expected result: The pasted text should be the plaintext without the markdown formatting characters.

However, the actual result is that the pasted text contains the plaintext without the markdown formatting characters.

  1. Copy with context menu: Right-click on the selected text and choose "Copy" from the context menu.
  2. Paste into a plaintext app: Paste the copied text into an app that only accepts plaintext, such as Notepad.
  3. Actual result: The pasted text contains the plaintext with the markdown formatting characters.

Expected Behavior

The expected behavior is that both methods of copying formatted text should behave consistently. Ideally, the right-click copy should behave the same as the Ctrl + C copy, stripping the markdown characters.

A. Consistent behavior: The behavior of copying with Ctrl + C and the context menu should be the same, stripping the markdown characters.

B. Ideal behavior: The right-click copy should behave the same as the Ctrl + C copy, stripping the markdown characters. This is because most users would not expect to get markdown formatting characters when copying from a wysiwyg editor.

Logs

No logs were provided with the issue report.

Conclusion

The inconsistent behavior of copying with context menu vs Ctrl + C from the RTE in Joplin is a notable issue that affects user experience. The expected behavior is that both methods should behave consistently, stripping the markdown characters. To resolve this issue, Joplin developers should investigate and address the underlying cause of this inconsistency.

Recommendations

  1. **Investigate the issue Joplin developers should investigate the cause of this inconsistency and identify the root cause.
  2. Implement consistent behavior: Joplin developers should implement consistent behavior for both methods of copying formatted text, stripping the markdown characters.
  3. Test and verify: Joplin developers should thoroughly test and verify the changes to ensure that the behavior is consistent and as expected.

Q: What is the current behavior of copying formatted text from the RTE in Joplin?

A: The current behavior is that when you copy formatted text using Ctrl + C, it pastes the plaintext without the markdown formatting characters. However, when you copy using the context menu, it pastes the plaintext with the markdown formatting characters.

Q: What is the expected behavior of copying formatted text from the RTE in Joplin?

A: The expected behavior is that both methods of copying formatted text should behave consistently, stripping the markdown characters. Ideally, the right-click copy should behave the same as the Ctrl + C copy, stripping the markdown characters.

Q: Why is it important to have consistent behavior for copying formatted text?

A: Consistent behavior is important because it provides a seamless and user-friendly experience for users. When users expect a certain behavior, it helps to build trust and confidence in the application.

Q: What are the potential consequences of not addressing this issue?

A: If this issue is not addressed, it may lead to user frustration and confusion. Users may become accustomed to using the context menu to copy formatted text, which may lead to inconsistent behavior in other areas of the application.

Q: How can I report this issue to the Joplin developers?

A: You can report this issue to the Joplin developers by submitting a bug report through the Joplin website or by contacting the Joplin support team.

Q: What are the system requirements for Joplin?

A: The system requirements for Joplin are as follows:

  • Operating System: Windows
  • Joplin Version: 3.3.12
  • Desktop Version Info: Joplin 3.3.12 (prod, win32)
  • Device: win32, Intel(R) Core(TM) Ultra 7 256V
  • Client ID: bce815a5276340048b4ff1dce1c47aee
  • Sync Version: 3
  • Profile Version: 47
  • Keychain Supported: Yes
  • Alternative instance ID: -
  • Revision: 4d790b6
  • Backup: 1.4.3
  • Journal: 2.0.0
  • Note Tabs: 1.4.0

Q: How can I troubleshoot this issue?

A: To troubleshoot this issue, you can try the following steps:

  1. Check the system requirements to ensure that your system meets the minimum requirements.
  2. Update Joplin to the latest version.
  3. Clear the cache and restart the application.
  4. Check for any conflicts with other applications or plugins.

Q: What are the next steps for the Joplin developers to address this issue?

A: The next steps for the Joplin developers are to investigate the cause of this inconsistency and identify the root cause. They should then implement consistent behavior for both methods of copying formatted text, stripping the markdown characters. Finally, they should thoroughly test and verify the changes to ensure that the behavior is consistent and as expected.

Q: How can I stay up-to-date with the latest developments on this issue?

A: You can stay up-to-date with the latest developments on this issue by following the Joplin blog or by joining the Joplin community forum.