Simplify New Compiler Pass Issue Template
Introduction
Creating a new compiler pass can be a complex task, and the existing issue template on GitHub can be overwhelming for developers who are new to the project. In this article, we will discuss how to simplify the new compiler pass issue template, making it a simple place to add ideas and suggestions.
The Current Issue Template
The current issue template on GitHub is a comprehensive document that covers various aspects of creating a new compiler pass. However, this template can be intimidating for developers who are new to the project. The template includes sections such as:
- Title: A brief description of the new compiler pass
- Description: A detailed explanation of the new compiler pass
- Motivation: The reason for creating the new compiler pass
- Proposal: A detailed proposal for the new compiler pass
- Design: The design of the new compiler pass
- Implementation: The implementation of the new compiler pass
- Testing: The testing of the new compiler pass
- Review: A review of the new compiler pass
Simplifying the Issue Template
To simplify the new compiler pass issue template, we can break it down into smaller sections. We can create a new issue template that includes only the essential information. This will make it easier for developers to add ideas and suggestions without feeling overwhelmed.
New Issue Template
The new issue template can include the following sections:
- Title: A brief description of the new compiler pass
- Description: A brief explanation of the new compiler pass
- Idea: A place to add ideas and suggestions for the new compiler pass
Benefits of Simplifying the Issue Template
Simplifying the new compiler pass issue template has several benefits. It makes it easier for developers to add ideas and suggestions, which can lead to a more collaborative and productive development process. It also reduces the complexity of the issue template, making it more accessible to developers who are new to the project.
Creating a Discussion Template
In addition to simplifying the issue template, we can also create a new discussion template to move over the more detailed proposal part of the existing template. This will allow developers to discuss and refine their ideas before submitting a formal proposal.
Benefits of Creating a Discussion Template
Creating a discussion template has several benefits. It provides a space for developers to discuss and refine their ideas, which can lead to a more informed and well-thought-out proposal. It also reduces the complexity of the issue template, making it more accessible to developers who are new to the project.
Example of a Discussion Template
The discussion template can include the following sections:
- Title: A brief description of the discussion
- Description: A brief explanation of the discussion
- Proposal: A detailed proposal for the new compiler pass
- Design: The design of the new compiler pass
- Implementation: The implementation of the new compiler pass
- Testing: The testing of the new compiler pass
- Review: A review of the new compiler pass
Conclusion
Simplifying the new compiler pass issue template and creating a discussion template can make it easier for developers to add ideas and suggestions, and to discuss and refine their ideas before submitting a formal proposal. This can lead to a more collaborative and productive development process, and can make it easier for developers who are new to the project to contribute.
Future Work
In the future, we can continue to refine and improve the issue and discussion templates. We can add more sections and fields to the templates, and we can make them more accessible and user-friendly. We can also create more templates and forms to support different types of contributions, such as bug reports and feature requests.
Recommendations
Based on our analysis, we recommend the following:
- Simplify the new compiler pass issue template to make it easier for developers to add ideas and suggestions.
- Create a discussion template to move over the more detailed proposal part of the existing template.
- Add more sections and fields to the templates to make them more accessible and user-friendly.
- Create more templates and forms to support different types of contributions.
Appendix
The following is an example of a simplified issue template:
| Field | Description |
|---|---|
| Title | A brief description of the new compiler pass |
| Description | A brief explanation of the new compiler pass |
| Idea | A place to add ideas and suggestions for the new compiler pass |
The following is an example of a discussion template:
| Field | Description | |
|---|---|---|
| Title | A brief description of the discussion | |
| Description | A brief explanation of the discussion | |
| Proposal | A detailed proposal for the new compiler pass | |
| Design | The design of the new compiler pass | |
| Implementation | The implementation of the new compiler pass | |
| Testing | The testing of the new compiler pass | |
| Review | A review of the new compiler pass |
Q: Why simplify the new compiler pass issue template?
A: Simplifying the new compiler pass issue template makes it easier for developers to add ideas and suggestions, which can lead to a more collaborative and productive development process. It also reduces the complexity of the issue template, making it more accessible to developers who are new to the project.
Q: What are the benefits of creating a discussion template?
A: Creating a discussion template provides a space for developers to discuss and refine their ideas, which can lead to a more informed and well-thought-out proposal. It also reduces the complexity of the issue template, making it more accessible to developers who are new to the project.
Q: How will the simplified issue template and discussion template be used?
A: The simplified issue template will be used for adding ideas and suggestions for new compiler passes. The discussion template will be used for discussing and refining ideas before submitting a formal proposal.
Q: Will the simplified issue template and discussion template be available for all contributors?
A: Yes, the simplified issue template and discussion template will be available for all contributors. This will make it easier for developers who are new to the project to contribute and for existing contributors to collaborate more effectively.
Q: How will the simplified issue template and discussion template be maintained?
A: The simplified issue template and discussion template will be maintained by the project maintainers. They will review and update the templates as needed to ensure they remain relevant and effective.
Q: Can I suggest changes to the simplified issue template and discussion template?
A: Yes, you can suggest changes to the simplified issue template and discussion template. Please submit your suggestions through the project's issue tracker or discussion forum.
Q: How will the simplified issue template and discussion template be communicated to contributors?
A: The simplified issue template and discussion template will be communicated to contributors through the project's documentation, issue tracker, and discussion forum.
Q: Will the simplified issue template and discussion template be translated into other languages?
A: Yes, the simplified issue template and discussion template will be translated into other languages to make them more accessible to contributors who speak different languages.
Q: How will the simplified issue template and discussion template be used in conjunction with other project tools?
A: The simplified issue template and discussion template will be used in conjunction with other project tools, such as the project's issue tracker and discussion forum, to facilitate collaboration and communication among contributors.
Q: Can I use the simplified issue template and discussion template for other projects?
A: Yes, you can use the simplified issue template and discussion template for other projects. However, please note that the templates may need to be adapted to fit the specific needs of your project.
Q: How will the simplified issue template and discussion template be evaluated?
A: The simplified issue template and discussion template will be evaluated based on their effectiveness in facilitating collaboration and communication among contributors. The project maintainers will review and update the templates as needed to ensure they remain relevant and effective.
Q: Can I provide feedback on the simplified issue template and discussion template?
A: Yes, you can provide feedback on the simplified issue template and discussion template. Please submit your feedback through the project's issue tracker or discussion forum.
Q: How will the feedback on the simplified issue template and discussion template be used?
A: The feedback on the simplified issue template and discussion template will be used to improve the templates and make them more effective in facilitating collaboration and communication among contributors.
Q: Can I request changes to the simplified issue template and discussion template?
A: Yes, you can request changes to the simplified issue template and discussion template. Please submit your request through the project's issue tracker or discussion forum.
Q: How will the request for changes to the simplified issue template and discussion template be evaluated?
A: The request for changes to the simplified issue template and discussion template will be evaluated based on its relevance and impact on the project. The project maintainers will review and update the templates as needed to ensure they remain relevant and effective.
Q: Can I provide suggestions for new features or improvements to the simplified issue template and discussion template?
A: Yes, you can provide suggestions for new features or improvements to the simplified issue template and discussion template. Please submit your suggestions through the project's issue tracker or discussion forum.
Q: How will the suggestions for new features or improvements to the simplified issue template and discussion template be evaluated?
A: The suggestions for new features or improvements to the simplified issue template and discussion template will be evaluated based on their relevance and impact on the project. The project maintainers will review and update the templates as needed to ensure they remain relevant and effective.