Unclear How Versioning Works
Introduction
Versioning is a crucial aspect of software development, ensuring that different versions of a project are properly tracked and managed. However, when it comes to the FHIR Core Inferno project, the versioning strategy appears to be unclear. This article aims to shed light on the versioning process and address the discrepancies found in the project's documentation.
The Release Strategy
According to the release strategy document on GitHub, the FHIR Core Inferno project follows a specific versioning approach. The document states that the versioning scheme is based on the semantic versioning (semver) standard, which consists of three numbers: major, minor, and patch. The major version is incremented when there are breaking changes, the minor version is incremented when new features are added, and the patch version is incremented for bug fixes.
However, upon further investigation, it appears that the latest content on the project's documentation does not follow this versioning strategy. This raises questions about the accuracy of the release strategy document and the versioning process in general.
Discrepancies in Versioning
There are several discrepancies in versioning that need to be addressed:
1. Unclear Versioning of '1.1.0.pre'
The version '1.1.0.pre' is listed as available on the Inferno test kits website. However, it is unclear what this version actually is or how it relates to the repository. Is it a pre-release version, a beta version, or something else entirely? The lack of clarity surrounding this version makes it difficult to understand the project's versioning strategy.
2. Last Entry in CHANGELOG.md
The last entry in the CHANGELOG.md file is version 0.0.18. This suggests that the project has not followed the semantic versioning standard, as the major version is still at 0.0. This raises questions about the project's versioning strategy and whether it has been consistently applied.
3. Missing Releases
The list of releases on the project's repository does not include a version 1.1.0.pre. This suggests that the version listed on the test kits website may not be a real release, or it may be a pre-release version that has not been properly documented.
4. Inconsistent Versioning
The README.md file states that the latest available version is 1.1.0. However, this version is not listed in the CHANGELOG.md file, and it is unclear what changes were made in this version. This inconsistency raises questions about the project's versioning strategy and whether it has been consistently applied.
Conclusion
The FHIR Core Inferno project's versioning strategy appears to be unclear, with discrepancies in versioning and inconsistent documentation. The release strategy document on GitHub suggests that the project follows a semantic versioning standard, but the latest content on the project's documentation does not follow this approach. To resolve these discrepancies, the project team needs to provide clear and consistent documentation on the versioning strategy and ensure that it is consistently applied across all project components.
Recommendations
To improve the versioning strategy and documentation, the project team should:
- Update the release strategy: Ensure that the release strategy document accurately reflects the project's versioning strategy and is consistently applied across all project components.
- Provide clear documentation on versioning: Provide clear and concise documentation on the versioning strategy, including what each version represents and how it relates to the project's repository.
- Ensure consistent versioning: Ensure that the versioning strategy is consistently applied across all project components, including the CHANGELOG.md file, the README.md file, and the test kits website.
- Communicate changes: Communicate changes to the versioning strategy and documentation to the project team and stakeholders to ensure that everyone is aware of the changes and can adapt accordingly.
Introduction
The FHIR Core Inferno project's versioning strategy has been a topic of discussion, with discrepancies in versioning and inconsistent documentation. To help clarify the versioning process, we have compiled a list of frequently asked questions (FAQs) and answers.
Q&A
Q: What is the FHIR Core Inferno project's versioning strategy?
A: The FHIR Core Inferno project follows a semantic versioning (semver) standard, which consists of three numbers: major, minor, and patch. The major version is incremented when there are breaking changes, the minor version is incremented when new features are added, and the patch version is incremented for bug fixes.
Q: Why is the version '1.1.0.pre' listed on the Inferno test kits website?
A: The version '1.1.0.pre' is a pre-release version, which means it is a version that has not been fully tested or released. It is unclear what this version actually is or how it relates to the repository.
Q: What is the difference between a pre-release version and a beta version?
A: A pre-release version is a version that has not been fully tested or released, while a beta version is a version that has been tested but is still in the development phase. The FHIR Core Inferno project does not use beta versions, but rather pre-release versions.
Q: Why is the last entry in the CHANGELOG.md file version 0.0.18?
A: The last entry in the CHANGELOG.md file is version 0.0.18 because the project has not followed the semantic versioning standard. The major version is still at 0.0, which suggests that the project has not made any significant changes or updates.
Q: Why is the version 1.1.0 listed in the README.md file not listed in the CHANGELOG.md file?
A: The version 1.1.0 listed in the README.md file is a version that has been released, but it is not listed in the CHANGELOG.md file because the project has not followed the semantic versioning standard. The CHANGELOG.md file only lists versions that have been released, but the project has not consistently applied this standard.
Q: How can I ensure that I am using the correct version of the FHIR Core Inferno project?
A: To ensure that you are using the correct version of the FHIR Core Inferno project, you should check the project's documentation and release notes for the latest version. You can also check the project's repository for the latest changes and updates.
Q: What should I do if I encounter any issues with the versioning strategy?
A: If you encounter any issues with the versioning strategy, you should contact the project team or submit an issue on the project's repository. The project team will work to resolve the issue and provide clear and consistent documentation on the versioning strategy.
Conclusion
The FHIR Core Inferno project's versioning strategy has been a topic of discussion, with discrepancies in versioning and inconsistent documentation. By answering these frequently asked questions, we hope to provide clarity on the versioning process and help users understand the project's development process.
Recommendations
To ensure that you are using the correct version of the FHIR Core Inferno project, we recommend:
- Checking the project's documentation: Check the project's documentation and release notes for the latest version.
- Checking the project's repository: Check the project's repository for the latest changes and updates.
- Contacting the project team: Contact the project team or submit an issue on the project's repository if you encounter any issues with the versioning strategy.
By following these recommendations, you can ensure that you are using the correct version of the FHIR Core Inferno project and can take advantage of the latest features and updates.