Showing A Closed Form Is Exact.

Introduction

In the realm of differential geometry, a closed form is a crucial concept that has far-reaching implications in various fields of mathematics and physics. A closed form is a differential form that satisfies a specific condition, which is essential for understanding many geometric and topological properties. In this article, we will delve into the concept of a closed form, explore the condition for a form to be closed, and provide a step-by-step guide on how to show that a given form is exact.

What is a Closed Form?

A closed form is a differential form that satisfies the condition:

$$D_k \alpha_{ij} + D_i \alpha_{jk} + D_j \alpha_{ki} = 0$$

where $D_k$ denotes the covariant derivative with respect to the $k$-th coordinate, and $\alpha_{ij}$ is a differential form of degree 2. This condition is also known as the Bianchi identity.

The Condition for a Form to be Closed

The condition for a form to be closed is a fundamental concept in differential geometry. To understand this condition, let's consider a differential form $\alpha$ of degree 2, which can be written as:

$$\alpha = \alpha_{ij} dx^i \wedge dx^j$$

where $dx^i$ and $dx^j$ are the basis 1-forms. The condition for $\alpha$ to be closed is given by:

$$(D_k \alpha_{ij} + D_i \alpha_{jk} + D_j \alpha_{ki})(x) = 0$$

This condition can be interpreted as follows: the covariant derivative of the form $\alpha$ with respect to the $k$-th coordinate, plus the covariant derivative of the form $\alpha$ with respect to the $i$-th coordinate, plus the covariant derivative of the form $\alpha$ with respect to the $j$-th coordinate, must vanish at the point $x$.

Showing a Closed Form is Exact

To show that a closed form is exact, we need to find a differential form $\beta$ such that:

$$d\beta = \alpha$$

where $d$ is the exterior derivative. This is equivalent to finding a form $\beta$ such that:

$$\beta = \beta_i dx^i$$

and:

$$d\beta_i = \alpha_{ij} dx^j$$

To find the form $\beta$, we can use the following steps:

1. Compute the exterior derivative: Compute the exterior derivative of the form $\alpha$:

$$d\alpha = D_k \alpha_{ij} dx^k \wedge dx^i \wedge dx^j$$

2. Find the form $\beta$: Find a form $\beta$ such that:

$$d\beta = D_k \alpha_{ij} dx^k \wedge dx^i \wedge dx^j$$

This can be done by integrating the expression:

$$\beta_i = \int D_k \alpha_{ij} dx^k$$

with respect to the $i$-th coordinate.

3. Verify the condition: Verify that the form $\beta$ satisfies the condition:

$$d\beta = \alpha$$

This can be done by computing exterior derivative of the form $\beta$ and checking that it is equal to the original form $\alpha$.

Example

Let's consider a simple example to illustrate the concept of a closed form and how to show that it is exact. Suppose we have a differential form $\alpha$ of degree 2, given by:

$$\alpha = (x^2 + y^2) dx \wedge dy$$

We can compute the exterior derivative of this form:

$$d\alpha = 2x dx \wedge dy + 2y dy \wedge dx$$

Since the exterior derivative of a form is always a form of degree 3, we can see that the form $\alpha$ is closed.

To show that the form $\alpha$ is exact, we need to find a form $\beta$ such that:

$$d\beta = \alpha$$

We can find the form $\beta$ by integrating the expression:

$$\beta = \int (x^2 + y^2) dx$$

with respect to the $y$-coordinate. This gives us:

$$\beta = x^2 y + f(x)$$

where $f(x)$ is an arbitrary function of $x$. We can verify that the form $\beta$ satisfies the condition:

$$d\beta = \alpha$$

by computing the exterior derivative of the form $\beta$ and checking that it is equal to the original form $\alpha$.

Conclusion

$$

Q: What is a closed form in differential geometry?

A: A closed form is a differential form that satisfies the condition:

$$D_k \alpha_{ij} + D_i \alpha_{jk} + D_j \alpha_{ki} = 0$$

where $D_k$ denotes the covariant derivative with respect to the $k$-th coordinate, and $\alpha_{ij}$ is a differential form of degree 2.

Q: What is the condition for a form to be closed?

A: The condition for a form to be closed is given by:

$$(D_k \alpha_{ij} + D_i \alpha_{jk} + D_j \alpha_{ki})(x) = 0$$

This condition can be interpreted as follows: the covariant derivative of the form $\alpha$ with respect to the $k$-th coordinate, plus the covariant derivative of the form $\alpha$ with respect to the $i$-th coordinate, plus the covariant derivative of the form $\alpha$ with respect to the $j$-th coordinate, must vanish at the point $x$.

Q: How do I show that a closed form is exact?

A: To show that a closed form is exact, you need to find a differential form $\beta$ such that:

$$d\beta = \alpha$$

where $d$ is the exterior derivative. This is equivalent to finding a form $\beta$ such that:

$$\beta = \beta_i dx^i$$

and:

$$d\beta_i = \alpha_{ij} dx^j$$

Q: What are the steps to show that a closed form is exact?

A: The steps to show that a closed form is exact are:

1. Compute the exterior derivative: Compute the exterior derivative of the form $\alpha$:

$$d\alpha = D_k \alpha_{ij} dx^k \wedge dx^i \wedge dx^j$$

2. Find the form $\beta$: Find a form $\beta$ such that:

$$d\beta = D_k \alpha_{ij} dx^k \wedge dx^i \wedge dx^j$$

This can be done by integrating the expression:

$$\beta_i = \int D_k \alpha_{ij} dx^k$$

with respect to the $i$-th coordinate.

3. Verify the condition: Verify that the form $\beta$ satisfies the condition:

$$d\beta = \alpha$$

This can be done by computing exterior derivative of the form $\beta$ and checking that it is equal to the original form $\alpha$.

Q: Can you provide an example of showing that a closed form is exact?

A: Let's consider a simple example to illustrate the concept of a closed form and how to show that it is exact. Suppose we have a differential form $\alpha$ of degree 2, given by:

$$\alpha = (x^2 + y^2) dx \wedge dy$$

We can compute the exterior derivative of this form:

$$d\alpha = 2x dx \wedge dy + 2y dy \wedge dx$$

Since the exterior derivative of a form is always a form of degree 3, we can see that the form $\alpha$ is closed.

To show that the form $\alpha$ is exact, we need to find a form $\beta$ such that:

$$d\beta = \alpha$$

We can find the form $\beta$ by integrating the expression:

$$\beta = \int (x^2 + y^2) dx$$

with respect to the $y$-coordinate. This gives us:

$$\beta = x^2 y + f(x)$$

where $f(x)$ is an arbitrary function of $x$. We can verify that the form $\beta$ satisfies the condition:

$$d\beta = \alpha$$

by computing the exterior derivative of the form $\beta$ and checking that it is equal to the original form $\alpha$.

Q: What are some common mistakes to avoid when showing that a closed form is exact?

A: Some common mistakes to avoid when showing that a closed form is exact include:

• Not computing the exterior derivative correctly: Make sure to compute the exterior derivative of the form $\alpha$ correctly.
• Not finding the form $\beta$ correctly: Make sure to find the form $\beta$ such that $d\beta = \alpha$.
• Not verifying the condition: Make sure to verify that the form $\beta$ satisfies the condition $d\beta = \alpha$.

By avoiding these common mistakes, you can ensure that your proof is correct and complete.