What Is The Likelihood That The Relic Of The True Cross Currently Housed At The Abbey Of Santo Toribio De Liébana In Spain Is Actually A Fragment Of The Cross Brought Back From Jerusalem By The Crusaders In 1099, Rather Than A Later Medieval Forgery Created To Legitimize The Abbey's Claims To Apostolic Succession?

by ADMIN 316 views

The likelihood that the relic of the True Cross at the Abbey of Santo Toribio de Liébana is a genuine fragment from the Crusaders in 1099, rather than a medieval forgery, is low. Here's the conclusion based on the analysis:

  1. Historical Context: The Crusaders brought back many relics, but the abbey's acquisition details are unclear. If the relic appeared later, it might indicate forgery.

  2. Documentation: The abbey's medieval sources may be biased. Without contemporary corroboration, the claim's reliability is questionable.

  3. Scientific Evidence: Radiocarbon dating could help, but if unavailable, the wood type (traditionally olive) might offer clues.

  4. Motivation: The abbey had incentives to possess such a relic for prestige and funding, suggesting possible forgery.

  5. Prevalence of Forgeries: The abundance of True Cross fragments by the 16th century implies many were forgeries.

  6. Legends and Miracles: Often used to authenticate relics, but don't prove genuineness.

In summary, while there's a possibility of authenticity, historical context and the prevalence of forgeries make it more likely that the relic is a medieval creation to enhance the abbey's status.